Spirited: Book vs. Movie

Spirited, directed by Sean Anders, reimagines Charles Dickens's book A Christmas Carol as a modern musical. Will Ferrell plays the Ghost of Christmas Present, whose attempt to reform Ryan Reynolds's Clint Briggs leads him to question his own life.

PollBook or movie, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the movie?

From Books Adapted

What changed from the book

The ghosts turn redemption into a business

Spirited uses the three visits in A Christmas Carol to build an original story about the people arranging them. Dickens follows Scrooge through his haunting; the movie gives the ghosts research, rehearsals and a crew preparing each new case. Clint Briggs occupies Scrooge's place in that process, with a new history and a modern job built around manipulating public opinion.

Sean Anders and John Morris began with the thought that the ghosts have the mission in Dickens's book. Anders said they modeled the organization behind the haunt on a movie crew. The musical's visible staging grows out of that idea: the spirits are putting on a show to change someone's life.

Contains spoilersTap to show

The reformed man gets a different future

Dickens ends with Scrooge living generously among the people he once ignored. Spirited takes its new Scrooge figure somewhere else: Clint dies and takes over Present's job. Anders said the possibility of Clint becoming the ghost was part of their thinking early on, though finding a way to reach it took longer. The movie keeps the book's change of heart while inventing a new life after it.

Your own listsKeep this adaptation on a list you make.
About the book and the movie
Book
A Christmas Carol cover
Author
Charles Dickens
Year
1843
Pages
106Buy book
Audiobook length
1 hr 5 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Andy Sacs

Ebenezer Scrooge treats Christmas as an interruption to business and other people's hardship as none of his concern. On Christmas Eve, his dead partner Jacob Marley arrives with a warning about the life Scrooge is making for himself. Three spirits lead him through Christmases past, present and still to come, forcing him to look beyond the money he has accumulated.

Movie
Spirited poster
Director
Sean Anders
Writer
Sean Anders, John Morris
Year
2022
Runtime
2 hr 7 minWatch on Amazon
Cast
Will Ferrell, Ryan Reynolds, Octavia Spencer, Patrick Page
Genre
Christmas, musical
IMDb
View on IMDb

The Ghost of Christmas Present chooses Clint Briggs, a professional manipulator, for the annual business of reforming a selfish human. Clint refuses to follow the expected script and starts questioning the spirit assigned to change him. Their encounters turn the planned redemption into an examination of Present's own history and unfinished business.

Movies based on A Christmas Carol

  1. Book vs. Movie
  2. Book vs. Movie
  3. Book vs. Movie
  4. Spirited2022You are hereWatch on Amazon
  5. Book vs. Movie

TV shows based on A Christmas Carol

  1. Book vs. Series
Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.