A Christmas Carol: Book vs. Series

A Christmas Carol, written by Steven Knight and directed by Nick Murphy, adapts Charles Dickens's book for television. The 2019 TV show stars Guy Pearce as Scrooge and takes an adult approach to the story of his Christmas reckoning.

PollBook or TV show, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the TV show?
Your own listsKeep this adaptation on a list you make.
About the book and the TV show
Book
A Christmas Carol cover
Author
Charles Dickens
Year
1843
Pages
106Buy book
Audiobook length
1 hr 5 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Andy Sacs

Ebenezer Scrooge treats Christmas as an interruption to business and other people's hardship as none of his concern. On Christmas Eve, his dead partner Jacob Marley arrives with a warning about the life Scrooge is making for himself. Three spirits lead him through Christmases past, present and still to come, forcing him to look beyond the money he has accumulated.

TV show
A Christmas Carol poster
Creator
Steven Knight
Writer
Steven Knight
Year
2019
Episode
58 minWatch on Amazon
Seasons
1
Episodes
3
Network
BBC One, FX
Cast
Guy Pearce, Andy Serkis, Stephen Graham, Joe Alwyn
Genre
Christmas, fantasy
IMDb
View on IMDb

Businessman Ebenezer Scrooge treats other people's suffering as an acceptable cost of making money. A succession of supernatural visitors forces him to revisit childhood trauma and the harm he has inflicted on others. His clerk Bob Cratchit and Bob's wife Mary struggle to protect their children from a man who uses their desperation against them.

Other adaptations of this book

  1. A Christmas CarolScrooge · Movie · 1970
    Details
    Scrooge poster
    Director
    Ronald Neame
    Writer
    Leslie Bricusse
    Year
    1970
    Runtime
    1 hr 53 min
    Cast
    Albert Finney, Alec Guinness, Edith Evans, Kenneth More

    London moneylender Ebenezer Scrooge dismisses the celebrations around him and sends his underpaid clerk home for Christmas. His dead partner's warning begins a night of encounters with three spirits. Through memories, household visits and visions of what may follow, Scrooge faces the losses his devotion to money has brought him in this musical retelling.

  2. A Christmas CarolScrooged · Movie · 1988
    Details
    Scrooged poster
    Director
    Richard Donner
    Writer
    Michael O'Donoghue, Mitch Glazer
    Year
    1988
    Runtime
    1 hr 42 min
    Cast
    Bill Murray, Karen Allen, John Forsythe, John Glover

    Television executive Frank Cross is overseeing a lavish Christmas broadcast while making the people around him miserable. A visit from his dead mentor interrupts the preparations, followed by three spirits determined to confront him with the life he has built. Frank's efforts to control the situation only make his increasingly chaotic Christmas Eve worse.

  3. A Christmas CarolThe Muppet Christmas Carol · Movie · 1992
    Details
    The Muppet Christmas Carol poster
    Director
    Brian Henson
    Writer
    Jerry Juhl
    Year
    1992
    Runtime
    1 hr 22 min
    Cast
    Michael Caine, Dave Goelz, Steve Whitmire, Jerry Nelson

    Ebenezer Scrooge begrudges his clerk Bob Cratchit even a day away from work for Christmas. That night, two dead business partners warn him that his greed has consequences, and three spirits arrive to demonstrate them. Gonzo, playing Charles Dickens, narrates Scrooge's journey with Rizzo as their subject resists every uncomfortable revelation.

  4. A Christmas CarolEbenezer · Movie · 2026
    Details
    Ebenezer poster
    Director
    Ti West
    Year
    2026
    Cast
    Johnny Depp, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin

    Ebenezer Scrooge is drawn into a supernatural journey through the London he knows and the life he has made there. Encounters with his past, present and possible future confront him with the consequences of his choices. The chance to change course depends on facing what those experiences reveal about him.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.