Charlotte's Web: Book vs. Movie

Gary Winick's 2006 film Charlotte's Web adapts E. B. White's book, combining live-action farm scenes with animated animals. Dakota Fanning plays Fern, and Julia Roberts voices the spider who sets out to save Wilbur.

PollBook or movie, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the movie?
About the book and the movie
Book
Charlotte's Web cover
Author
E. B. White
Year
1952
Pages
184Buy book
Audiobook length
4 hr 2 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Meryl Streep, January LaVoy, Kirby Heyborne, MacLeod Andrews, Emily Rankin, Kimberly Farr, Mark Deakins, Lincoln Hoppe, Tavia Gilbert, Robin Miles, Cassandra Campbell, Danny Campbell, Full Cast

Fern saves the smallest pig in a litter and names him Wilbur, but growing up means moving to her uncle's barn. There he befriends Charlotte, a spider who learns that he is being raised for slaughter. With few ways to influence the humans outside the pen, she sets about making them see Wilbur differently.

Movie
Charlotte's Web poster
Director
Gary Winick
Writer
Susannah Grant, Karey Kirkpatrick
Year
2006
Runtime
1 hr 37 minWatch on Amazon
Cast
Dakota Fanning, Julia Roberts, Steve Buscemi, John Cleese
Genre
children's, Comedy
IMDb
View on IMDb

Wilbur arrives in the Zuckermans' barn after Fern persuades her father to spare his life. He is eager to make friends, but the other animals know what usually happens to a spring pig when winter comes. Charlotte, a spider living above his pen, recruits help for a plan that turns the farm into a local attraction and may give Wilbur a future.

Other adaptations of this book

  1. Charlotte's WebMovie · 1973
    Details
    Charlotte's Web poster
    Director
    Charles A. Nichols, Iwao Takamoto
    Writer
    Earl Hamner Jr.
    Year
    1973
    Runtime
    1 hr 34 min
    Cast
    Debbie Reynolds, Paul Lynde, Henry Gibson, Rex Allen

    On the Zuckermans' farm, Wilbur learns that being well fed is no guarantee of a long life. His friend Charlotte promises to help, using words woven into her web to change the farmer's plans. Barnyard songs, an unwilling rat's errands and preparations for the county fair accompany the animals' effort to make an ordinary pig seem extraordinary.

  2. Charlotte's WebE.B. White's Charlotte's Web · Series · 2025 · HBO Max
    Details
    E.B. White's Charlotte's Web poster
    Year
    2025
    Episode
    45 min
    Seasons
    1
    Episodes
    3
    Network
    HBO Max
    Cast
    Amy Adams, Elijah Wood, Griffin Robert Faulkner, Jean Smart

    A young pig named Wilbur finds companionship in Charlotte, a spider whose quiet corner of the barn becomes a refuge from loneliness. When his future on the farm is threatened, she uses her web to persuade the humans to value him. Across this three-part animated story, their friendship draws the other animals into an effort to keep a promise.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.