Treasure Island: Book vs. Movie

Victor Fleming's 1934 movie Treasure Island adapts Robert Louis Stevenson's book. Jackie Cooper plays Jim Hawkins opposite Wallace Beery's Long John Silver, a ship's cook whose plans put a treasure-hunting voyage in danger.

PollBook or movie, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the movie?
Your own listsKeep this adaptation on a list you make.
About the book and the movie
Book
Treasure Island cover
Author
Robert Louis Stevenson
Year
1883
Pages
116Buy book
Audiobook length
6 hr 5 minGet audiobook
Narrator
AI Voice Alex Mercer

A dead sailor's papers lead Jim Hawkins to a map of Captain Flint's buried treasure. Sailing aboard the Hispaniola, Jim befriends the ship's cook, Long John Silver, before overhearing plans for a mutiny. The voyage leaves him caught between the expedition's leaders and pirates who want the fortune for themselves.

Movie
Treasure Island poster
Director
Victor Fleming
Writer
John Lee Mahin
Year
1934
Runtime
1 hr 45 minWatch on Amazon
Cast
Wallace Beery, Jackie Cooper, Lionel Barrymore, Otto Kruger
Genre
adventure, pirate, treasure hunt
IMDb
View on IMDb

Jim Hawkins finds a treasure map among the possessions of Billy Bones, a sailor who dies at his mother's tavern. A wealthy squire finances a voyage, and Jim forms an attachment to ship's cook Long John Silver. The discovery that Silver intends to betray the expedition leaves the boy caught between friendship and loyalty.

Other adaptations of this book

  1. Treasure IslandMovie · 1950
    Details
    Treasure Island poster
    Director
    Byron Haskin
    Writer
    Lawrence Edward Watkin
    Year
    1950
    Runtime
    1 hr 36 min
    Cast
    Bobby Driscoll, Robert Newton, Basil Sydney, Walter Fitzgerald

    Cabin boy Jim Hawkins admires Long John Silver, the cook aboard an expedition to find Captain Flint's treasure. Silver encourages the friendship while quietly gathering the men he needs to take the ship. When Jim discovers the plan, the captain asks him to keep playing the trusting boy so they can learn what the pirates intend.

  2. Treasure IslandMovie · 1990
    Details
    Treasure Island poster
    Director
    Fraser Clarke Heston
    Writer
    Fraser Clarke Heston
    Year
    1990
    Runtime
    2 hr 12 min
    Network
    TNT
    Cast
    Charlton Heston, Christian Bale, Oliver Reed, Christopher Lee

    The arrival of pirate Billy Bones brings danger to the inn Jim Hawkins runs with his mother, along with papers leading to a hidden fortune. Jim sails aboard the Hispaniola as cabin boy, unaware that much of its crew once served Captain Flint. Discovering their intentions forces him to help the loyal officers survive a mutiny.

  3. Treasure IslandMuppet Treasure Island · Movie · 1996
    Details
    Muppet Treasure Island poster
    Director
    Brian Henson
    Writer
    James V. Hart, Kirk Thatcher, Jerry Juhl
    Year
    1996
    Runtime
    1 hr 39 min
    Cast
    Tim Curry, Billy Connolly, Jennifer Saunders, Kevin Bishop

    Jim Hawkins leaves his dreary work at an inn after a dying sailor entrusts him with a treasure map. With Gonzo and Rizzo, he joins a voyage led by Captain Smollett and financed by Squire Trelawney. Ship's cook Long John Silver befriends Jim, but his plans for the treasure threaten everyone aboard.

  4. Treasure IslandTV show · 2012 · Sky Group
    Details
    Treasure Island poster
    Director
    Steve Barron
    Writer
    Stewart Harcourt
    Year
    2012
    Episode
    1 hr 30 min
    Seasons
    1
    Episodes
    2
    Network
    Sky Group
    Cast
    Eddie Izzard, Toby Regbo, Rupert Penry-Jones, Daniel Mays

    Jim Hawkins sees a chance to leave his mother's struggling inn when he finds a map to a pirate's treasure. The voyage brings him close to Long John Silver, whose friendship conceals a plan to seize the ship. With greed dividing the expedition, Jim must judge whom he can trust before they reach the island.

  5. Treasure IslandMovie · 2027
    Details
    Director
    Ridley Scott
    Year
    2027
    Cast
    Hugh Jackman, Hugh Grant, Owen Cooper

    The discovery of a treasure map sends a boy on an ocean voyage in search of a hidden fortune. Among the men sailing with him is Long John Silver, a pirate whose charm conceals his ambitions. Reaching the treasure means surviving a contest with someone far more experienced at deception.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.