The Princess Bride: Book vs. Movie

Rob Reiner’s 1987 film The Princess Bride adapts William Goldman’s 1973 novel, with a screenplay by Goldman. Buttercup and Westley’s romance becomes an adventure involving a kidnapping, a prince, and a determined rescue.

PollBook or movie, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the movie?

From Books Adapted

What changed from the book

The book's imaginary editor becomes a grandfather

Goldman's novel pretends to be an abridgment of a much older book by S. Morgenstern. Morgenstern is invented. So is the account of Goldman cutting that author's long book down to the adventure his father read to him as a child.

The movie adapts the central adventure as a complete story, but replaces Goldman's commentary with a grandfather reading to his grandson. Their interruptions preserve the act of telling and questioning the story. Director Rob Reiner said their growing closeness was central to his adaptation, even though their scenes occupy only a small part of it.

Contains spoilersTap to show

The rescue loses the Zoo of Death, and the ending loses its uncertainty

The book puts a series of dangerous animals between Inigo and Fezzik and the imprisoned Westley. The movie removes the Zoo of Death and uses the Pit of Despair instead. Cary Elwes said the animals were beyond the movie's budget.

The escape also changes in tone. The novel questions whether its apparent happy ending will last. The movie gives Westley and Buttercup their final kiss, then returns to the grandfather and grandson. Reiner described that closing exchange as the completion of their own story: the boy who resisted being read to now wants his grandfather to return.

About the book and the movie
Book
The Princess Bride cover
Author
William Goldman
Year
1973
Pages
399Buy book
Audiobook length
2 hr 32 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Rob Reiner

Presenting himself as the editor of a longer tale by the fictional S. Morgenstern, William Goldman recounts the adventures of Buttercup and her beloved Westley. A royal engagement, a kidnapping, and a pursuit through dangerous territory bring swordsmen, a giant, and a scheming prince into their path, with the narrator repeatedly interrupting to argue with the story he is telling.

Movie
The Princess Bride poster
Director
Rob Reiner
Writer
William Goldman
Year
1987
Runtime
1 hr 34 minWatch on Amazon
Cast
Cary Elwes, Mandy Patinkin, Chris Sarandon, Christopher Guest, Wallace Shawn, André the Giant, Robin Wright, Fred Savage, Peter Falk
Genre
cinematic fairy tale, Fantasy, pirate, romantic comedy, swashbuckler, sword and sorcery
IMDb
View on IMDb

A grandfather reads an adventure to his sick grandson, beginning with a farm boy’s devotion to Buttercup and her later engagement to a prince. When kidnappers carry her away, a masked pursuer follows through duels and the Fire Swamp, while the boy listening keeps interrupting to question the story’s rules and romantic developments.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.