The Plot Against America: Book vs. Series

David Simon and Ed Burns's 2020 HBO TV show The Plot Against America adapts Philip Roth's book. It imagines Charles Lindbergh becoming president and follows a Jewish family in Newark as the country's politics intrude on its home life.

PollBook or TV show, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the TV show?

From Books Adapted

Which books each season covers

Six episodes retell the book with a different conclusion

SeasonBook material used
1The Plot Against America, adapted as a six-part story with expanded viewpoints and a rewritten ending.
A guide, not an exact match: shows move scenes and storylines between books and seasons.

The TV show follows the book's main alternate history through to its own conclusion. It does not stop partway through Roth's story with the rest reserved for a later season.

What changed from the book

Philip no longer has to witness everything

The book presents the events as Philip's memories of childhood. For television, Simon and Ed Burns spread the story across six characters' viewpoints and wrote scenes absent from the book. Simon explained that keeping Philip as the sole viewpoint would have required extensive narration or put the child physically present at too many events. The adults can instead have experiences that reach Philip only through conversation in the book.

Contains spoilersTap to show

The final election offers less reassurance

Roth's book restores Roosevelt to the presidency. The TV show ends without an election result. It shows voters being turned away and ballots being destroyed, adding threats to the vote itself. Simon tied that uncertainty to American voting in 2020.

How it was adapted

Roth asked for distance from his own family

The family's surname changes from Roth to Levin at the author's request. Simon said Roth felt that actors and other writers would inevitably make the characters different from the family he had imagined. Giving them another name would preserve some distance from his real relatives. Roth discussed the adaptation with Simon before his death, but did not live to see the finished TV show.

Your own listsKeep this adaptation on a list you make.
About the book and the TV show
Book
The Plot Against America cover
Author
Philip Roth
Year
2004
Pages
480Buy book
Audiobook length
13 hr 23 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Ron Silver

In an imagined 1940 election, the aviator Charles Lindbergh, an isolationist who has publicly blamed Jews for pushing America toward war, defeats Franklin Roosevelt. A young Philip Roth watches the consequences unfold in his Newark family, where disagreements over the new president become inseparable from growing fears about their place in America.

TV show
The Plot Against America poster
Creator
David Simon, Ed Burns
Writer
Ed Burns, David Simon
Year
2020
Episode
1 hr 1 minWatch on Amazon
Seasons
1
Episodes
6
Network
HBO
Cast
Winona Ryder, Anthony Boyle, Zoe Kazan, Morgan Spector
Genre
alternate history, Drama
IMDb
View on IMDb

The Levin family watches Charles Lindbergh's rise to the presidency with conflicting hopes and fears in an alternate version of 1940s America. As antisemitism gains political legitimacy, their disagreements over resistance, accommodation and safety put pressure on the household and its relationships with relatives and neighbors.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.