The Christmas Candle: Book vs. Movie

The Christmas Candle is John Stephenson's 2013 movie based on Max Lucado's 2006 book. Hans Matheson plays a minister who questions an English village's faith in a candle said to bring a Christmas miracle.

PollBook or movie, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the movie?

From Books Adapted

What changed from the book

The movie moves the village forward a generation

The movie retells Lucado's single book with a later setting. The book dates Reverend Richmond's arrival in Gladstone to May 4, 1864. The movie calls the village Gladbury, moves the story to 1890 and makes electric lighting part of Richmond's conflict with the candlemaker.

The later setting gives the movie a concrete dispute over how the village will change: the minister's modernization threatens a tradition built around candles.

Fewer villagers carry the story

Screenwriter Candace Lee said choosing which of Lucado's characters to keep was one of the adaptation's main difficulties. She and Eric Newman narrowed the cast of characters while trying to preserve the sense of a community acting together.

Your own listsKeep this adaptation on a list you make.
About the book and the movie
Book
The Christmas Candle cover
Author
Max Lucado
Year
2006
Pages
208Buy book
Audiobook length
1 hr 44 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Ben Holland

In nineteenth-century Gladstone, candlemaker Edward Haddington and his wife Bea await the angel whose touch gives one candle the power to bring a miracle. Many villagers need help, leaving the couple with a difficult choice about who should receive it. The approaching Christmas also brings a minister who questions the place of the tradition in their faith.

Movie
The Christmas Candle poster
Director
John Stephenson
Writer
Candace Lee, Eric Newman
Year
2013
Runtime
1 hr 40 minWatch on Amazon
Cast
Hans Matheson, Samantha Barks, Lesley Manville, Sylvester McCoy
Genre
Christmas, fantasy
IMDb
View on IMDb

In the English village of Gladbury, an angel is said to bless a candle every twenty-five years, granting a miracle to whoever lights it. Newly arrived Reverend David Richmond challenges the villagers' reliance on the tradition. As Christmas approaches in 1890, his attempts to introduce electric lighting put him further at odds with the candlemakers and their neighbors.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.