The Black Dahlia: Book vs. Movie

Brian De Palma's 2006 movie The Black Dahlia adapts James Ellroy's book, a fictional investigation of Elizabeth Short's murder. Josh Hartnett and Aaron Eckhart play detectives whose involvement in the case disrupts their partnership and personal lives.

PollBook or movie, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the movie?

From Books Adapted

How much of the book it covers

Ellroy's story is compressed into one movie

The movie adapts Ellroy's single book about the Dahlia case, rather than attempting a separate reconstruction of the real murder. Screenwriter Josh Friedman said he worked from the book. An early screenplay developed with David Fincher ran to 175 pages; after Brian De Palma joined, they removed about 50 pages.

Friedman said the shorter version gave more space to the mystery and fewer detours into the characters' lives. He still regarded the love triangle as at least as important as the investigation. Ellroy was not involved in writing the screenplay.

What changed from the book

Elizabeth Short appears in invented auditions

In the book, Elizabeth Short is largely someone the living characters discuss and imagine. De Palma's movie gives her a filmed presence through staged audition footage, with Mia Kirshner playing Short.

Ellroy said he initially resisted the idea because he wanted her to remain someone described by others, as in his book. After seeing the scenes, he felt they gave viewers a stronger connection to her death and made Bucky's growing obsession visible. The auditions are an adaptation device, not recovered footage of the real woman.

Your own listsKeep this adaptation on a list you make.
About the book and the movie
Book
The Black Dahlia cover
Author
James Ellroy
Year
1987
Pages
368Buy book
Audiobook length
13 hr 55 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Stephen Hoye
Series
L.A. Quartet

Los Angeles police officers Bucky Bleichert and Lee Blanchard become consumed by the murder of Elizabeth Short, whose mutilated body makes her notorious as the Black Dahlia. Their search leads through Hollywood's promises and exploitation while drawing out obsessions neither man can keep separate from his work. This fictional account of the real killing turns the investigation into a threat to the investigators' own lives.

Movie
The Black Dahlia poster
Director
Brian De Palma
Writer
Josh Friedman
Year
2006
Runtime
2 hrWatch on Amazon
Cast
Josh Hartnett, Aaron Eckhart, Scarlett Johansson, Hilary Swank
Genre
Crime, crime drama, crime thriller, Drama, film noir, horror, LGBTQ-related, mystery, neo-noir, thriller
IMDb
View on IMDb

Former boxers Bucky Bleichert and Lee Blanchard become police partners in 1940s Los Angeles, where the murder of aspiring actress Elizabeth Short takes over their working lives. Lee grows dangerously obsessed with the investigation. Bucky's search brings him into the orbit of a wealthy family, complicating his loyalties to his partner and Lee's girlfriend Kay.

L.A. Quartet movies in order

  1. Book vs. Movie
  2. 2The Black Dahlia2006You are hereWatch on Amazon

Other books in this series

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.