A Series of Unfortunate Events (2004): Books vs. Movie

Brad Silberling’s 2004 film adapts The Bad Beginning, The Reptile Room, and The Wide Window by Lemony Snicket. Jim Carrey plays Count Olaf, who pursues the Baudelaire children’s inheritance as they search for a safe home.

PollBooks or movie, which was better?
Do you recommend the books?
Do you recommend the movie?

From Books Adapted

How much of the book it covers

One movie combines the first three books

The movie uses The Bad Beginning, The Reptile Room and The Wide Window, books 1–3 of Daniel Handler's series written as Lemony Snicket. It does not reach the end of the thirteen-book story.

Director Brad Silberling said the filmmakers saw those three books as material for one continuous narrative.

No second movie was made. Books 4–13 were left out of this version; the later Netflix series, A Series of Unfortunate Events, is a separate adaptation that covers all thirteen.

What changed from the book

Contains spoilersTap to show

The first book's wedding moves to the end

Olaf's plan to marry Violet belongs to the ending of The Bad Beginning. The movie holds it back until after the stories of Uncle Monty and Aunt Josephine, making it the climax of the combined adventure.

An invented attempt to kill the children takes its earlier place: Olaf locks them in a car on a railroad track. The children escape that danger before moving on to the next guardian.

The books, in order

  1. 1The Bad Beginning1999KindlePaperbackAudiobook
    Details
    The Bad Beginning cover
    Author
    Daniel Handler
    Year
    1999
    Pages
    176
    Audiobook length
    2 hr 29 min
    Narrator
    Tim Curry
    Series
    A Series of Unfortunate Events, book 1

    Violet, Klaus, and Sunny Baudelaire lose their parents and home in a fire, leaving a fortune they are too young to control. Their new guardian, Count Olaf, puts them to work in his filthy house and recruits them for a play with his theater troupe. When the siblings discover what he intends the performance to accomplish, they must find a way to stop him without help from the adults responsible for their care.

  2. 2The Reptile Room1999KindlePaperbackAudiobook
    Details
    The Reptile Room cover
    Author
    Daniel Handler
    Year
    1999
    Pages
    168
    Audiobook length
    3 hr 11 min
    Narrator
    Tim Curry
    Series
    A Series of Unfortunate Events, book 2

    Uncle Monty welcomes the Baudelaire children into a house filled with reptiles and begins planning an expedition to Peru that will include all three of them. For the first time since their parents died, they have a guardian who enjoys their company and values their talents. Then Monty hires an assistant the children recognize as Count Olaf, and their warnings fail to convey just how dangerous the newcomer is.

  3. 3The Wide Window2000KindlePaperbackAudiobook
    Details
    The Wide Window cover
    Author
    Daniel Handler
    Year
    2000
    Pages
    240
    Audiobook length
    3 hr 4 min
    Narrator
    Lemony Snicket
    Series
    A Series of Unfortunate Events, book 3

    Aunt Josephine fears almost everything, yet her home above Lake Lachrymose is supposed to keep the Baudelaires safe. When a sailor calling himself Captain Sham wins her trust, the children recognize Count Olaf beneath his disguise. Josephine’s disappearance leaves behind a note whose strange grammatical mistakes may offer their only chance of avoiding another spell in his custody.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.