Generation Kill: Book vs. Series

HBO's 2008 TV show Generation Kill adapts Evan Wright's nonfiction book about accompanying a Marine reconnaissance unit during the invasion of Iraq. David Simon, Ed Burns and Wright wrote the seven-part adaptation.

PollBook or TV show, which was better?
Do you recommend the book?
Do you recommend the TV show?

From Books Adapted

Which books each season covers

Seven episodes condense the invasion account

SeasonBook and material used
1Generation Kill, Evan Wright's nonfiction account of traveling with First Recon during the invasion of Iraq. All seven episodes adapt this one book.
A guide, not an exact match: shows move scenes and storylines between books and seasons.

The TV show follows the book's main invasion narrative rather than stopping partway through it for another season. The sequence of events stays largely intact, but dialogue is moved and rearranged. The book contains more material than the adaptation retains.

What changed from the book

The reporter stays, but his narration goes

The book gives Wright's first-person account. The TV show keeps him as a character but removes his narration of events. His background explanations of Recon culture are not delivered in voice-over; the Marines' behavior and conversations have to carry that information.

Wright initially wanted the TV show to leave him out altogether. Simon argued that removing the reporter would leave an unexplained empty seat in the Humvee or require an invented Marine to fill it. They kept Wright in the story, but wrote him as a witness rather than its central figure.

Your own listsKeep this adaptation on a list you make.
About the book and the TV show
Book
Generation Kill cover
Author
Evan Wright
Year
2004
Pages
354Buy book
Audiobook length
13 hr 22 minGet audiobook
Narrator
Patrick Lawlor

Reporter Evan Wright accompanies the Marines of the First Reconnaissance Battalion during the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Drawing on his time embedded with the unit, he records their conversations, combat experiences and encounters with civilians, examining how young men trained for war respond to confusion, violence and the decisions of their commanders.

TV show
Generation Kill poster
Creator
David Simon
Writer
David Simon, Ed Burns, Evan Wright
Year
2008
Episode
1 hrWatch on Amazon
Seasons
1
Episodes
7
Network
HBO
Cast
Alexander Skarsgård, James Ransone, Lee Tergesen, Jon Huertas
Genre
Drama, miniseries, War
IMDb
View on IMDb

As American forces invade Iraq in 2003, a Marine reconnaissance unit moves north with a Rolling Stone reporter riding alongside its men. The troops face uncertain orders, supply problems and encounters with civilians, while their banter and rivalries continue through the danger and confusion of the advance.

Add a comment with your vote, optional
What people said

No comments yet. Vote, then say why.